"Our direct bookings are down. Where do we start?" It's one of the most common questions marketing leaders bring to us. The natural response is to increase spend or launch a new campaign, because those are the easiest things to change. But adding budget before understanding why bookings have dropped can mean spending more on something that was already working.
A better place to start is the customer journey. Understanding who books, when they make their decisions, what prompts them to start researching and where they drop off helps you find where a change could make the biggest difference. For businesses with longer buying journeys, that opportunity is often somewhere other than where most of the marketing budget is going.
In this blog, we'll show you how to work backwards from your business goal, what to look for in the customer journey, how to identify the biggest opportunity and how to test a change before investing in it.
Why start with the business before the metrics?
Before opening your analytics, get clear on the business goal you're trying to achieve and how far you are from it. Metrics only tell you something useful when you understand what you're measuring them against. Otherwise, it's easy to spend time explaining changes in traffic, clicks and conversions without identifying which ones actually matter to the business.
It's also important to understand which outcomes are most valuable. For a luxury lodge we work with, travel agents take their commission out of the room rate, meaning a direct booking is worth more than the same booking through trade. That makes direct bookings a more useful starting point than traffic or reach, and changes which pages and marketing channels we need to focus on.
What should you read in the customer journey?
There are four things we look at when mapping a customer journey: who books, how far ahead they book, what starts their research and where they stop. Each helps narrow down where the opportunity sits. Together, they show you how customers move towards a decision and where your marketing needs to support them.
Who books? Different products can attract very different audiences, even within the same business. At the lodge, accommodation guests came mainly from Australia and the US, while New Zealanders were more likely to book the restaurant. Understanding these differences matters because each audience needs a different journey, rather than one message trying to serve everyone.
How far ahead do they book? This tells you when your marketing needs to reach people and how much time you have to influence their decision. The lodge's US guests previously booked around 180 days before travelling, but now book around 120 days ahead. That gives campaigns a third less time to work and makes the pages customers visit close to booking more important.
What starts their research? Understanding where demand originates helps you decide whether you need to create more interest or do a better job of converting the interest you already have. For high end travel, research often starts with press coverage in international newspapers, luxury magazines and travel blogs. If those sources are already generating interest, spending more on awareness won't necessarily address a problem further along the journey.
Where do they stop? Look at the pages customers visit as they get closer to making a decision and whether they continue towards booking. This is often where you can find a more specific opportunity than simply trying to attract more visitors.
How do you find the point that moves the most?
Once you've mapped the journey, look for the point where you have plenty of people arriving but too few taking the next step. Often it's a well visited accommodation, product or itinerary page that isn't doing enough to help someone make a decision. Improving that page can benefit everyone who passes through it, rather than paying to bring more people into the same experience.
The changes you make should reflect how your customers actually decide. For a luxury stay page, that could mean leading with the largest suites to establish price expectations, making it clear what every room includes, and bringing awards and rankings further up the page. An invitation to plan a stay with a concierge may also better suit guests who expect a conversation, rather than simply presenting them with a standard booking button.
You can then connect those improvements to the marketing that's already generating demand. For example, building a retargeting audience from visitors who arrived through press coverage allows you to follow up with the benefits of booking direct. You're using what you've learned about the journey to connect the right message, page and audience at the point they're making a decision.
How do you prove a change before you pay for it?
You don't need to commit to a full website project to find out whether an improvement will work. We build a working version of the proposed page on a subdomain, using the client's existing style, and split traffic between the original and the new version. By measuring bookings from each, we can see whether the change makes a difference before the client commits development budget.
This has changed how we approach website improvements. Previously, we saw a page redesign as a substantial project involving a designer, developer and lengthy build before anything could be tested. Now we can get a working page in front of people quickly, which is why every user experience and AI search visibility project we run includes building the proposed change, rather than just presenting it in a slide.
It's also a more practical way to get meaningful changes approved. A full redesign requires a significant investment in an idea that hasn't been tested, so naturally it comes with more scrutiny. Testing makes the decision smaller and reversible, giving you evidence to support a bigger change rather than asking the business to fund it on confidence alone.
What if the journey shows a gap a page cannot fix?
Not every opportunity can be addressed by improving a page. Sometimes the journey reveals that customers are missing the content they need to make a decision. For one tourism operator, the pages selling the trip had no video showing what the experience actually feels like, leaving an important gap in how the experience was presented.
We estimated that better creative could generate around $200,000 in additional revenue. That gave the marketing team a clearer business case to take to their board when requesting a video budget, rather than simply arguing that the website needed better content.
Understanding where the content fits in the journey also gives you a much better creative brief. You can tell the production team exactly which part of the decision the video needs to support, while giving the board a clearer view of the return the investment is intended to deliver.
Where do you start this week?
Start with one business goal that isn't meeting expectations and establish how far you are from target. Then work through the customer journey behind it: who books, how far ahead they decide, what prompts their research and which pages they visit before booking.
Look for the page attracting the most visitors but doing the least to move them towards the next step. Rather than starting with another campaign or a bigger budget, identify one change you think will help those visitors make a decision, build it and test it. That's how you turn an understanding of the customer journey into an improvement you can measure.
Which page is holding your bookings back?
Your traffic tells you how many people arrive. Your customer journey tells you where they stop, and which change would move your bookings most.
We map your journey against your business goal, find that change, then build it and test it on your own booking numbers before you commit budget to a rebuild.
See how we do itRather talk it through first? Book a call. Want to keep up as the ground shifts? Get our newsletter.

Written by
Dave Hockly
Director
Dave founded Data Story with a belief that better data leads to better marketing. With over a decade in digital marketing across tourism, hospitality, and growth businesses, he specialises in turning complex analytics into clear business strategy. Dave leads client relationships and oversees the agency's strategic direction.
LinkedInRelated articles

SEO & GEO
How destinations can improve performance using category search SEO
28 September 2026
Category search happens when a traveller knows the kind of trip they want but has not chosen where to take it. We show which pages reach these undecided searchers and how to build them.
Read article
Destination and Experience
Your destination does not have an awareness problem
23 September 2026
How to tell whether awareness is your problem, and what to fix before you fund another campaign.
Read article
Paid Media
Why pay commission on guests you already won?
13 August 2026
Your brand, your reputation and your marketing earn the guest. Then the booking goes to an OTA, and the commission and the guest relationship go with it. How to use Google Hotel Ads to hold on to the booking, the relationship and the data.
Read article